“But we do have a Portfolio Management!” recently claimed a CIO, who couldn’t understand why his projects permanently struggled from resource issues. Definitely: Portfolio Management (PPM) serves to utilize scarce resources – probably the usual case – at a maximum of business benefits. Benefits are measured by the contribution to achieve (strategic) business goals. But PPM is not a tool but a transparent and consistent process by which the portfolio is managed (which can be supported by a tool). And this needs to be consequently applied if it is to help !

I’d like to show three missed prerequisites as reasons why in my example here the PPM was to fail:
- Who wants to meet objectives needs to have such ! And they need to be harmonically coordinated, e.g. with a Balanced Scorecard or categories like long-term (such as growth, market position etc.) and short-term goals (e.g. innovation, market entry etc.) and sustainability. If strategic objectives compete or even contradict the portfolio will not be efficient, and also will not achieve it’s targets effectively.
- Prioritize – and keep with it ! Following the priorities the resources are to be assigned to the projects, not opportunistic or because someone is yelling louder. That doesn’t mean it would be impossible to change priorities due to better insight, but changing direction frequently doesn’t help achieving targets.
- Never do more than you can ! Those are doing right who do the yearly planning for the project pipeline by matching the planned capacities with the desired projects’ efforts in sequence of their priority. But if you find you also urgently need X, Y and Z to be done (on top), and you add further initiatives during the course of the year, you will overwhelm your organization’s capabilities and capacity for suffering. And you don’t need to wonder why not more but less than planned is finished…
I wish that more managers in the C-Suite would self-limit their “flexibility” and “autonomy of decision” in favor of comprehensible decision processes and a realistic discipline of expectations, thus increasing their business results effectively and efficient by a structured PPM. And by the way they will strengthen their employees’ motivation and significantly improve projects’ results (time, cost, quality, business benefits).
Learn more about implementing Project Portfollio Management accurately…

The organization no longer fits to its market
There is only help in a transformation of the organization and corporate culture concerning established hierarchies, responsibilities, compensations, thinking and priorities etc. towards an organization focused on the project business. In a pure line organization this means the change to a matrix “function vs. project”. At an already matrix-organized company it will be the implementation of a third dimension on peer-level to the existing ones. What it takes and what to pay attention to I have described in my article “



In Europe enterprises typically have an established line organization structure with functional and central departments. This is especially the case in our traditionally strong industries like Mechanical and Plant Engineering and in particular in privately owned, mid-size companies, but also at consulting and IT firms, engineering and development bureaus etc. Often I find a distinctive own life of the departments, production locations or plants with silo thinking, insufficient communication and cooperation. This becomes very evident with cross-functional work in projects.
Project management as a core competency and strong department. Quit with functional specialists who lead the projects at the side. Project management needs full attention on planning, coordination and leadership – actually same as with corporate management. Time and objective conflicts of two hearts in the project leader’s chest are poison for concentrating on the essentials. His “thinking” also needs to be project-driven, no longer product love struck. Everybody contributes his core competence, the engineer his functional knowledge, and the project manager his PM skills, for success of the total. Process models and best practices make it replicable and calculable.
Functional and central departments as service providers for the projects. The previously gone through change in your corporate project culture will help you here. The engineers’ provisions will now not only serve for the product’s perfection but also for the whole task’s delivery to contract. Procurement will not only look at the terms and conditions but also (may be even sometimes with concessions supporting the project targets) at the reliability of delivery. Legal will probe partnership in collaboration; QM controls the project’s product quality and drives process quality (Continuous Improvement). HR will search for skills instead of positions, train for future project requirements, take care for a corporate identity among the employees, etc.


Well, you won’t receive an assignment of responsibility for such a mega initiative if you didn’t show some real good performance and results as a PM before. But that’s insufficient in most cases for a programme if you are not familiar with additional PgM methodology and action to take.
